‘The texts by Gillian Brock and Mills et al. (winter term lecture 10) argue for the abolition of immigration of health workers from poor to rich countries’. Do you agree that this is the basic message of these two texts?

For this essay, you should choose one of the following essay tasks:

1. ‘The texts by Gillian Brock and Mills et al. (winter term lecture 10) argue for the abolition of immigration of health workers from poor to rich countries’. Do you agree that this is the basic message of these two texts?

2. What would Peter Singer’s (winter term lecture 11) view be on what Gillian Brock (winter term lecture 10) calls ‘compatriot priority’?

3. Susanne Sophia Spiliotis (winter term lecture 8) discusses ‘historical injustice’ in the context of corporations and injustices committed in their name. Compare what Spiliotis writes on this subject with what Michael Sandel writes about ‘Dilemmas of loyalty’ in chapter 9 of Justice (fall term: lecture 11).

4. Chandran Kukathas and Matthias Risse (winter term lecture 9) both argue in favour of relatively free immigration. Outline their respective arguments in favour of immigration and pay particular attention to the differences in their justifications.